Nothing explains this song quite like seeing James Taylor play it on Youtube. [link] It's a bit of an anthem from the time. The album Sweet Baby James was released in March of 1970, and the single a month or so later. Discussions about this song are complicated by the passage of 40 years since its release. Mr Taylor still plays and sings the song, but he sure looks different.
I'd like to avoid spending a lot of time on the "meaning" of "Fire and Rain." Taylor has commented enough times that we know who Suzanne is, and what "flying machines in pieces on the ground" means. Suzanne was a friend who committed suicide, The Flying Machine was an old band that didn't work out, and fire and rain referred to electric shock therapy and the cold showers that followed. And if you ask me, it isn't important.
The song is a song about loss, about happiness that fled like the end of a day. And there's a bit of hope – "Won't you look down upon me, Jesus. You've got to help me make a stand." And the use of past tense to describe the struggles hints that life goes on after loss, one day at a time.
Part of the point of this post is to describe the kind of talent that James Taylor represented in the time between 1968 and 1970. He was one of the first acts signed by Apple Records. When the Beatles think your music is good, that's saying something. His first album, James Taylor, was advertised on billboards like this one [link]. Taylor was a skilled songwriter from the beginning, and he had a unique style playing acoustic guitar. James Taylor didn't invent the hammer-on and the slide, but he did expand the art form. His skills with guitar were broader than I suspected at first. When I heard the "Steamroller Blues" I was shocked at how fast he played.
Any discussion about "Fire and Rain" would be incomplete without talking about the people who have covered it. Cher. Rick Wakeman. Don't bother listening to the Ramsey Lewis version – it's just too hard to imagine a soul-searing pain of shock therapy and cold showers with a cute rumba beat.
Growing up, I liked the Blood Sweat & Tears cover – it was different enough from the original, and yet still had that stark feeling that I think the song calls for.
"Fire and Rain" was simply the advent of a long career for a great artist, a folk singer-songwriter who brings a hope, an enthusiasm, a love of life, and a wonderful artistic gift to us mass-peoples.

